U.K., Spanish, Irish Banks' Costs to Rise as ECB Tightens Rules

By Charles Penty and Jon Menon

Sept. 5 (Bloomberg) -- Banks in the U.K., Spain and Ireland that have relied on the European Central Bank for low-cost funding will have to pay more as it tightens lending rules.

ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet, concerned that some banks were abusing its willingness to make loans backed by securities most investors won't accept, said yesterday the central bank will increase the so-called ``haircut'' on securities used as collateral for loans to 12 percent from as little as 2 percent, meaning it will lend just 88 percent of their value.

``It's a call to discipline from the ECB,'' said Tomas Varela, chief financial officer at Banco Sabadell SA, Spain's fourth-largest bank, which holds about 5 billion euros ($7.2 billion) of securities that will be worth less after Feb. 1, 2009, under the new ECB rules. ``It's a signal to the financial industry to start opening up more normal avenues of liquidity.''

The ECB, which lent 467 billion euros last week to banks with operations in the 15-country euro area, accepts a broader range of collateral for loans than the Federal Reserve or the Bank of England, including bonds with credit ratings five levels below AAA and asset-backed securities. This leeway prompted some firms to create bonds specifically as collateral for ECB borrowing.

``It is a bit like a drug, and they don't want the banks to become dependent on it,'' said Neil Smith, a Dusseldorf-based analyst at WestLB AG. ``There have been concerns the facility is being exploited, and the ECB wants the banks to start finding alternative ways of funding their business.''

Spanish and British banks fell the most yesterday in European trading after the ECB clampdown. HBOS Plc, the U.K. mortgage lender that has tapped the ECB via its Irish operation, fell 7 percent. Barclays Plc, the country's third-biggest lender, slumped 6 percent.

`Waking Up'

``People are waking up to the fact that the support scheme is getting rather bigger than the ECB is comfortable with,'' Goodwin said.

Barclays and HBOS spokesmen declined to comment on yesterday's ECB decision or say how much they have borrowed.

In Madrid, Banco Sabadell fell 3.2 percent, Banco Santander SA, the country's largest bank, sank 4 percent and Bankinter SA, fell 5.3 percent.

While Varela said the tightening will have a ``marginal'' impact on Banco Sabadell, which has taken no more than 500 million euros under the ECB program, Spain's share of ECB borrowing increased to 10.8 percent from 4 percent a year ago, according to Bank of Spain data. Spanish banks borrowed a record 49.4 billion euros from the ECB as of last month.

`Bad News'

``This is clearly bad news for the profit and loss of banks, especially Spanish and Irish-based ones, that have retained asset- backed securities,'' said Luca Jellinek, head of interest-rate strategy in London at Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc. ``ECB financing is a significant feature of their balance sheet.''

ECB lending to Irish banks more than doubled to 44.1 billion euros in the year through July, the central bank in Dublin said. About half goes to Dublin-based units of lenders from outside Ireland, according to Eamonn Hughes at Goodbody Stockbrokers.

HBOS, with a unit in Ireland, is among British banks that borrowed from the ECB, said Mamoun Tazi, an analyst at MF Global Securities Ltd.

``It highlights the dependency of U.K. banks on the central banks for a significant proportion of their funding,'' said Sandy Chen, an analyst at Panmure Gordon in London. ``With a significant increase in the cost of that funding, the read across is into earnings and the liquidity issues that gave rise to the funding programs in the first place.''

Winners, Losers

Central banks made borrowing easier after losses from subprime mortgage defaults in the U.S. caused credit markets to seize up worldwide. Banks have lost or written down $509 billion since the credit crisis began last year, with Europe accounting for $230 billion.

The cost of protecting European bank bonds from default rose yesterday to the highest in five months.

``The losers are the banks retaining bonds to raise cheap collateral, now the cost will be higher,'' said Jellinek at Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc. ``The winners are the rest of the euro system whose collateral has been edged out.''