European Officials Squabble Over Response to Crisis

By Brian Parkin

Oct. 2 (Bloomberg) -- European officials squabbled over how to respond to the global credit crunch, with Germany opposing a coordinated approach and the Netherlands calling on states to set aside funds to help troubled banks.

French President Nicolas Sarkozy distanced himself from comments by his finance minister Christine Lagarde over the need to set up a ``rescue fund.'' Luxembourg Prime Minister Jean- Claude Juncker told DeutschlandRadio today he didn't ``see the need'' for an effort to emulate the $700 billion rescue package that U.S. senators passed yesterday.

The conflict undermined efforts to build a consensus European strategy to counter the financial crisis as a recession looms. Other fissures emerged, as Ireland's decision to guarantee bank deposits and debts prompted criticism by British bankers yesterday that it ``distorted competition.''

``I cannot see a common response,'' Jean Peyrelevade, former chief executive officer of French bank Credit Lyonnais SA, now owned by Credit Agricole SA, said in an interview. ``For this crisis it's too late to build a common response.''

Fallout from the crisis that drove Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. into bankruptcy hit Europe this week, with Germany, France, Belgium, Luxembourg, Iceland and the U.K. rescuing five lenders and Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi pledging to prevent losses for depositors.

Euro Weakens

The euro tumbled against the dollar amid the infighting among European leaders. The Senate's vote in favor of the rescue plan for financial companies today also gave the dollar a boost. The euro fell to $1.3884 per euro at 13:05 p.m. in Frankfurt, near a one-year low, from $1.4009 yesterday in New York.

Dutch Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende will discuss his plan for European Union nations to create accounts to support their finance industry when he meets Sarkozy in Paris today, Dutch Finance Ministry spokeswoman Hendrieneke Bolhaar said.

``If all European countries reserve funds, it will add up to hundreds of billions of euros and that provides trust to Europeans,'' Dutch Finance Minister Wouter Bos told parliament today. ``The funds will be strictly national, although we need to reach consensus over when to use them.''

In the U.S., Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson proposed a $700 billion bailout on Sept. 20 that lawmakers are struggling to pass. The House of Representatives rejected a version of the plan three days ago. Senators who approved the package urged opponents in the House to drop their objections.

`Non-Starter'

A European version of the Paulson plan is a ``non-starter'' because of competing agendas and coordination difficulties, Klaus Baader, chief European economist at Merrill Lynch and Co. in London, said in a Sept. 29 report. Still, he expects increased cooperation among governments confronting the crisis.

The disagreements will be aired at an Oct. 4 meeting called by Sarkozy in Paris with Juncker, leaders of Great Britain, Italy and Germany, as well as European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet.

Lagarde told the German newspaper Handelsblatt in an interview today that a ``rescue package'' was needed to help ``smaller'' European states ``threatened with a banking failure.'' Germany opposes the proposal ``based on its current assessment of risk,'' said Finance Ministry spokesman Stefan Olbermann.

``We see no need for a fund,'' Olbermann said today.

Reuters reported that the fund would total 300 billion euros ($420 billion), citing an unnamed European government official.

Sarkozy Denial

Speaking to reporters today in Paris, Sarkozy said he ``denied the amount and the principle'' of such a fund.

``Everyone is working very well together,'' Lagarde told reporters in Paris today.

The specifics of a coordinated plan notwithstanding, Germany rejects a Europe-wide approach to bank rescues, said Torsten Albig, another finance ministry spokesman.

``The idea of applying one solution, one big bang'' should the banking crisis spread ``is not practicable and would create new, enormous problems,'' he told reporters yesterday in Berlin. ``The tailor-made solution is the right way.''

That contrasts with pleas from European Union officials for less unilateral action. Charlie McCreevy, EU financial-services commissioner, yesterday proposed more coordinated oversight and rules that banks hold additional capital for asset-backed bonds.

``Capital and strong financial institutions are the lifeblood of an economy,'' McCreevy said in a Bloomberg Television interview in Brussels.

Money Markets

As banks hoarded cash, the Libor-OIS spread, a gauge of cash scarcity, widened for an eighth day. The difference between the three-month London interbank offered rate for dollars and the overnight indexed swap rate widened 7 basis points to 254 basis points as of 8:44 a.m. in London. It averaged 8 basis points in the 12 months to July 31, 2007, before the credit squeeze spurred by the U.S. subprime- mortgage crisis began.

The credit-market turmoil may require a more comprehensive approach in Europe, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development said yesterday.

``Considering the exposure of European financial institutions, we might have to start thinking of a systemic plan for Europe if things don't improve on the other side of the Atlantic,'' OECD Secretary General Angel Gurria said in Paris. ``The piecemeal approach may not work in Europe either.''

A group of economists including Alberto Alesina of Harvard University and Klaus Zimmerman of Berlin's DIW economic institute appealed for an EU initiative to recapitalize banks.

`Once-in-a-Lifetime'

``This is a once-in-a-lifetime crisis,'' the 10 academics said in an emailed statement. European leaders need to tackle the bank industry's crisis ``head on before it spirals out of control.''

One proposal is for European countries to follow Ireland, either as a bloc or individually, in guaranteeing banks' deposits and debts. Spain's Finance Ministry today said it supports strengthening EU protections of deposits. Berlusconi and Sarkozy have already pledged to prevent losses for depositors.

The advantage of such a program would be that it would boost confidence among banks and give them time to resolve their problems, although it would also put taxpayer funds at greater risk, economists at Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc. said in a report today.

To contact the reporters on this story: Brian Parkin in Berlin at bparkin@bloomberg.net